Brenda Tracy, a rape survivor and advocate, is taking legal action against Michigan State University’s former head football coach, Mel Tucker, and the institution itself, seeking $75 million in damages.
In a notice of intent to sue filed in a Michigan court, Tracy alleges sexual harassment by Tucker, failure of the school to properly investigate her claims, and unauthorized disclosure of her identity to the media.
Her attorney, Karen Truszkowski, confirmed the intention to sue but declined further comment.
Tracy’s complaint stems from a December 2022 report to MSU’s Title IX office, where she detailed Tucker’s alleged sexual comments and behavior during an April 2022 phone call. The incident was brought to light by USA Today last September, prompting Tracy to express her profound disappointment and sense of betrayal. She revealed feeling re-traumatized by Tucker’s actions, suggesting he sought her out only to inflict further harm.
In her legal filings, Tracy asserts that MSU assured her confidentiality during their investigation but failed to prevent her identity from being leaked to the press by an unknown party affiliated with the university. This breach led to threats against Tracy and her family, which persist to this day.
Tucker, who was fired by MSU on September 27 following the media report and subsequent investigation, defended himself in a statement obtained by CNN. He characterized the phone call with Tracy as a consensual, private exchange between two consenting adults. Tracy plans to pursue two separate lawsuits against Tucker, MSU, and others involved—one under her name for $50 million and another under her nonprofit organization, “Set The Expectation,” for $25 million. These lawsuits encompass over 20 potential claims, including intentional infliction of emotional distress and breach of confidentiality.
Tracy’s advocacy work against sexual violence led her to establish “Set The Expectation,” through which she educates athletes on the importance of preventing such misconduct. Her advocacy stems from personal experience, having been raped in 1998 by four college football players. Despite her traumatic past, Tracy maintained ties with Michigan State, serving as an honorary captain for the team’s spring football game in 2022. A photo of her with Tucker was posted on the team’s Instagram account.
Tucker, who took over as head coach in 2020, achieved significant success in his second season, leading the team to an 11-2 record and signing a lucrative 10-year, $95 million contract. However, allegations of harassment emerged during the following season, leading to Tucker’s suspension and subsequent termination after just two games in 2023.
The legal battle between Tracy and MSU underscores broader issues of accountability and transparency within institutions, particularly in cases involving allegations of sexual misconduct. Tracy’s pursuit of justice reflects her unwavering commitment to advocating for survivors and holding perpetrators accountable for their actions.
