A US federal court has dismissed all charges against former President Donald Trump concerning mishandling classified documents post-presidency.
The ruling, delivered on Monday, July 15, 2024, centered on the appointment of Senior Counsel Jack Smith, deemed unconstitutional by the court.
Appointed by US Attorney General Merrick Garland in November 2022, Jack Smith was tasked with overseeing investigations into alleged interference in the 2020 election and the mishandling of classified documents found in various unsecured locations at Trump’s Mar-a-Lago residence.
These sensitive cases warranted the appointment of a special counsel to ensure impartiality and transparency, especially in politically divisive matters.
Trump swiftly moved to challenge the indictment related to classified documents, arguing that Smith’s appointment violated the Appointments Clause of the US Constitution.
This clause stipulates that certain officers of the United States must be nominated by the President and confirmed by the Senate, unless authorized by Congress.
District Judge Aileen Cannon, in her ruling, reluctantly acknowledged Smith’s argument that he qualified as an “inferior” officer.
However, she found that Smith’s appointment lacked statutory authorization required by the Constitution, emphasizing the separation of powers fundamental to US governance.
The court’s decision marks a victory for Trump, who has faced multiple legal challenges since leaving office. Earlier this year, the Supreme Court granted him prosecutorial immunity for acts related to his presidential duties.
Trump, consistent in his claims of political persecution, celebrated the court’s decision on social media, calling for an end to what he described as weaponization of the justice system.
This development follows recent accusations against President Joe Biden regarding mishandling classified materials during his vice presidency, a case also led by a special counsel.
The Justice Department opted not to prosecute Biden earlier this year, citing insufficient evidence to support criminal charges.
Trump’s legal battles continue to shape the political landscape as he remains a prominent figure in the 2024 presidential race, despite an apparent assassination attempt days before this court ruling.
